FOREKNOWLEDGE AND PREDESTINATION
© Orest Solyma  Dec 2, 2000  Edited Feb 2001
The Church of God in Williamstown
WEB SITE: http://www.alphalink.com.au/~sanhub/index.htm

INTRODUCTION
This subject matter is so vast, so meaningful, so controversial among scholars and philosophers that it might seem futile to speak about it so briefly. Though I seem to be saying that of almost every subject, necessity drives me to make the attempt—on the basis of Scripture and not from presumptions (Ps 19:13). However, one might say my assumptions are that the Scriptures speak the truth by the Spirit of truth to those who have ears to hear (1Cor 2:10-16). Many Christian groups and scholars agree that the Scriptures speak the truth, but personal interpretations make for numerous differences. Incoherency in the varied interpretations, biblical inconsistency and contradiction are problematic (Jn 10:35). Though there are hundreds of verses about truth, the following examples are guidelines used here (Pss 25:5; 43:3; Is 25:1; 43:9; Jer 4:2; Jn 17:17; Rom 1:18; 1Cor 2:10-16; 2Th 2:13; 1Jn 4:6; Rev 22:18-19).

The more understanding of the Word of God there is the more difficulty I find in obeying Him perfectly. The more God reveals Himself the more depths of sin I see everywhere. I'm compelled to turn to Him ever more. That ever-present experience, the struggle against sin, Galatians 5:17 describes:

This is characteristic of Christians who endure in overcoming. It is painfully described by the apostle Paul in Romans 7 and by the king and prophet David in Psalms 19, 51 and 139. This mystery of godliness, as 1Tim 3:16 calls it, integral to the mystery of God (Rev 10:7), continues to pre-occupy my thoughts. Therefore, suffer me longer still as I try to reveal more of some finer points of what I'm being taught.

The overpowering call to holiness—Be holy as God is holy—demanded in 1Pet 3:16 and Lev 11:45 is a searching and seeking by each of us and is a gift from God. The sanctification and perfection process is for becoming a holy people, a holy priesthood, a holy nation, and Kingdom of God and His Christ. It is foreordained for the elect, as 1Pet 2:4-5,9-10, Ex 19:5-6 and many other Scriptures say. May I explain some of the mystery of this foreordination and predestination of the precious saints.

FATE AND DETERMINISM
Whenever people, particularly scholars and philosophers, talk about foreknowledge and predestination the supposed problem of loss of free choice arises. Scripture nowhere speaks of one's fate being predetermined against one's righteous will-will as defined by God. Scripture does speak of one's fate because of one's persistent unrighteous will and as is revealed in case studies such as that of Cain and Judas. The wages of sin is death (Rom 6:23; Ezk 18:4; Gen 2:17). The Will of God is that none should perish, but people will perish; and the Will of God is that all should be saved, but not all people will be saved. Scriptures such as 1Tim 2:4, 2Pet 3:9, Rev 20:15, 21:8 say so. The devilish self-deception, falsehood, excuse for hidden personal sin and rejection of perfect overcoming—called universal salvation—I've addressed in the recent message, What Can Each of Us Give?—Faith and Works.

The Bible says much of choosing and doing righteousness, of wrongly choosing and doing unrighteousness (Gen 2:16-17; Rev 22:11-12). God urges us to choose righteousness and to consider our latter end, which are the consequence of our motives, thoughts and deeds. Moses, in the last month or so of his life, spoke God's Will to Israel and to us (Dt 1:3; Josh 1:1):

We are asked to choose to live as God would have us live—choose to follow the Way of Life Christ reveals. Too often people choose as their self-willed and deceiving desires drive them and not as the Holy Spirit urges. Each of us must ask ourselves these kinds of questions, "What am I choosing to do? Where am I going? How am I going? Why am I going there?" The minds of man, however, are driven by the god of this world who rejects knowledge of pure answers to these questions (2Cor 4:3-4; Eph 2:2-3; 6:12; 1Jn 5:19; Rev 12:9).

Such directives to consider, as in Deuteronomy from the Almighty God, are commands each of us should choose. If we fail to choose the Way of God we are determining our own end—it's the result and consequence of our choice. If we wholeheartedly and enduringly choose to obey His Will, seek His grace, His willing help and interventions, then we know our end (Ps 119:2; Jer 17:5-10). Paul expresses this confidence in his last epistle:

This apostle came to the end of his life having knowingly chosen the Life of God, having carefully observed the spiritual Law, having fully considered his latter end—Paul knew where he was going and he knew why he was going there. Paul chose the perfection God demands and provides (Gal 2:20; Col 1:27-29).

Responsibility and reward according to works are biblical. Fatalism, which is the attitude that it makes no difference what we might do because the future is unaffected by our present actions, is an anti-biblical way of thinking. Determinism is the idea that future events are as fixed and unalterable as the past is fixed and unalterable. Determinism says that all our choices, decisions, intentions, motives, and actions are no more than effects of other equally fateful events. But we are not part of an ancient Greek tragedy or demonic comedy (see Fatalism, Determinism in The Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy, 1997; The Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy, [1995]; Fernandez-Armesto & Wilson, Reformation, [Bantam, 1996], pp 87-90; Ferguson, Wright, Packer, editors, New Dictionary of Theology [IVP, 1993], Predestination).

Fatalism or determinism is biblically misinformed, illogical, philosophically indefensible. It is not in God's nature to be capricious, whimsical, mutable, selfish, unfair, self-serving. Such concepts are alien to the gracious nature of the Almighty God! I am certain, on the basis of Scripture, also philosophically and logically, that God, who never lies and who promised eternal life before time began (Tit 1:2), who is perfect in every way (Mt 5:48), who is completely fair, excellently equitable, lovingly merciful, gives each person free moral agency and free choice. And this free choice each of us should exercise according to His Laws and Principles. That is biblical teaching even before the Garden of Eden—for Lucifer knew that (see Satan and History).

Adam and Eve chose wrongly, although they had been instructed in righteousness (Gen 2:8,15-25). Their self-deception was the product of their own failures which God foresaw. It is absurd to suggest that GOD should have created an Edenic couple so that they would not sin. This would mean that they were automatons and puppets. Adam and Eve knew their choices were wrong. Those wrongs were the result of weaknesses, failures to heed what they knew was right, and refusal to repent, refusal to admit to their weakness (e.g., see Mk 9:24; Lk 17:5). Why do we refuse to immediately turn to righteousness rather than persist in error? Why are we sometimes unable to do righteousness? Why do we reject obedience to every Word of God for our own self-deceiving comfort? Whatever psychological or pseudo-logical reasons we might give, we know we are responsible and we know we are free to choose! Compulsion to error is the product of our own lusts and illusions, which overcome the will to righteousness. James 1:12-18 verifies this: Every person is tempted by his own lust (v 14). The human problem is that all too often the deceitful mind refuses to see its lusts and deceitful desires (Jer 17:5,9; Rom 8:7).

Habitual denial of problems and the refusal to make the emotional and intellectual effort to overcome evil with good produce spiritual neurosis. To choose otherwise results in overcoming, improving emotional health, increasing intellectual and spiritual strength, and the rewards and joys of victory (Gal 5:22-25; Phil 1:9-11; Col 1:11-14). The alternative to the latter brings persistent spiritual and moral weaknesses, anxiety problems, intellectual weakness, and all kinds of fears (Rom 8:15-17; 2Tim 1:7; 1Jn 4:18).

Judas, despite Jesus' appeals, chose the path of betrayal. God foreknew that he would, of his own will, choose an evil path. Psalms 41:7-9, 55:12-21, 69:6-12,22-28, 109:1-20,29 speak of Judas and those who choose like him. The appeals to Cain in Genesis 4, and the appeals to religious leaders during Christ's apostleship are examples of the fact that people who choose to live in error are foreknown as those who will refuse righteousness. Nowhere does the Bible suggest that people are doomed by God's choice—for it is His will that all should be saved, but many choose otherwise. We cannot choose to obey most of the Law most of the time and expect to inherit eternal Life. Likewise, we cannot choose just a little of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and expect Life (contra Mt 5:48).

FOREKNOWLEDGE AND PROPHECY
The contemplation of the glory of God is awesome and very satisfying. It is satisfying and logical to think of God as being without beginning and without end. Any other consideration becomes illogical and leads to absurdity. It is gratifying to accept from Scripture that:

I find these Scriptures beautiful, magnificent, wondrous. Does this mean that I know the dynamics of how the Almighty God understands all things, how He knows all things, how He has infinite foreknowledge? No. I readily admit I do not have perfect answers for such questions. But it makes good sense that the God who is the Almighty is almighty! If there were any weakness or any caprice in God then there could be no certainty, nor consistency, nor coherence. We could not be confident in Him nor in His prophecies. GOD the Father is not and cannot be less than almighty! He is omnipotent. Omniscience, prescience, and foreknowledge are necessary aspects of His being all-powerful.

Prophecy (e.g., as in Gen 49, Num 24, in most of Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, Revelation) is probably the most readily understood proof of God's foreknowledge. Prophecy is not prediction by God of things He will manipulate to come to pass. Divine prophecy foresees how history will develop and eventuate. Satan may try to make God a liar, but God has foreseen his attempts. God has not lied and will not lie. Disbelief in the Divine qualities is a product of denial and deceit (Ps 14:1-4).

How are we affected by the thoughts that consider the implications of the Lamb of God having been chosen before the creation of the universe?

1Pet 1:20 is prophecy expressing the Father's omniscience before the creation that the redemptive sacrifice of the Lamb of GOD would be necessary and at a particular time (also see Heb 1:2-3). It cannot be a surprise then that the fruits-to-be of that self-denying divine sacrifice are expressed in similar language by the apostle Paul. Before time began, before the creation, the Plan of God was there waiting to be manifested. The angelic host pays close attention to what is happening to the saints. Eph 3:9-10 offers an explanation for this. The purpose of God, the Gospel of Salvation, is known to the angelic hosts of Heaven. Satan and his demons likewise knew the Gospel but continue to proclaim counterfeit gospels which vast numbers accept as forms of Christianity (see Mt 24:11,24; Jn 8:44-45; 2Cor 4:4; Gal 1:6-9; 2Th 2:8-12; 2Tim 3:1-5,13; 2Pet 2:1-3; 1Jn 4:1,6; 5:19; Rev 12:9). The Gospel of God was known by the true disciples of the ancient past—such as Abraham (Gal 3:8; Heb 11). However, there is further revelation in seeing it all progressively unfold, for the prophets inquired and searched diligently just how and when the promises of salvation would occur and the angelic realm wants to know the manner and time-scale that will still unfold. We still don't know many of the details. False prophets continue to impress their blind followers.

1Pet 1:10-12, like Eph 3:9-10, speaks of the prophets and angelic host in these terms:

Revelation is progressive, just as the number of the saints keeps building until the full number is reached (Rev 14:1-4; 7:4-8). Hence the angels and demons watch the saints closely, for then they see more of the details of God's foreknowledge in the processes of history. God expresses His purposes in those He foresees as choosing to accept His work in them (Jn 6:29). Many who are called come to reject and fail to continue to choose all of God's righteousness. Christ's longest parable, the parable of the sower, illustrates this so graphically in Mt 13:1-23, in Mk 4:1-20 and Lk 8:1-15. El Shaddai or Shaddai, God the Almighty, occurs about 48 times in the OT. The LXX uses the Greek, pantokrator, all-powerful; the Latin uses omnipotens. God cannot be even slightly less than omnipotent. God cannot, likewise, be less than omniscient, i.e., He does know everything. If He doesn't know everything, what doesn't He know? How do we decide what He doesn't know? Perhaps we could tell Him what He shouldn't know? And how would He decide what He shouldn't know? Some maintain that God chooses not to know some things. Does He pretend not to know or does He reject not knowing? How would He then know that He should urgently know that He has chosen not to know? Do you know what you have chosen to not know? We could make more sarcastic comment. Since stupid assumptions invite folly, let's avoid self-deceiving presumptions and unreasonable declarations.

God is perfectly righteous, unsurpassed in love and wisdom, perfect in knowledge and character. The God I presently know, as described in the Scriptures, is not the God most speculative theology attempts to impose upon us.

Ps 33:11 confirms God's omniscient power:

Paul in Rom 11:33-36 says: There is no searching of His understanding, Isaiah 40:28 states (see also vv. 13-18; 42:9; 44:7; 45:21; 66:18).

It is these kinds of teachings that influence my considerations about the nature of God and the nature of the foreordained Christian calling. With the Lamb of God and the Plan of Salvation foreknown, it logically follows that those who follow the Lamb are foreknown.

PREDESTINATION OF THE SAINTS
Scholars who comment on God's foreknowledge and predestination of the saints generally make a point of saying that the Scriptures about God's foreknowledge and election of the saints speak corporately, that is, there is a Body of saints, the elect, and specific individuals are not meant as Rom 8:28-30 and Eph 1:3-10 reveal (e.g., Alan Richardson, An Introduction to the Theology of the New Testament [London: SCM Press, 1958], pp 271-81; Brendan Byrne, S.J., Romans [Collegeville: Liturgical Press, 1996], pp 304-307).

Since the OT and NT are consistent in Christian doctrines, we would expect teaching on predestination and foreknowledge in both to be mutually confirming. Let's consider the biblical concept of name in the Book of Life.

The apostle Paul says to the Church in Philippi that certain women, Clement, and other fellow workers have their names in the Book of Life (Phil 4:3; and also see Ex 32:32-33; Is 4:3; Dan 12:1; Lk 10:20; Heb 12:23; Rev 3:5; 20:12,15; 21:27; 22:19).

Those who will ultimately be in the City of God have their names in the Book of Life (Rev 21:27). Those whose names are not in the Book of Life are cast into the Lake of Fire (Rev 20:15; 22:19; Ps 69:27-28). And those whose names are not in the Book of Life will be deceived by the Beast that ascends from the bottomless Pit (Rev 13:8; 17:8). God foreknows—for reasons illustrated by Cain, Ishmael, Esau, Judas—that such people predictably refuse and will refuse to believe and love the truth. Such people choose differently to Abel, Isaac, Jacob, Peter. Those who overcome to the end and grow in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ will receive a new name which includes the Name of God and the City of God (Rev 2:12; 14:1; 22:4). 2Thess 2:9-12, Dan 11:30-32 and 12:10—in the context of tribulation—speak of those who self-determine to turn away from the Way God graciously offers. They adamantly prefer their own ways (see 2Pet 2:12-17; Jude 8-16; Gal 4:22-31; Heb 12:16; Mal 1:2-3).

Since God knows our hearts, He knows those who want to know what He sees in their hearts. Prov 20:27, 1Cor 2:10-16, Ps 19:12-14, and Ps 51:1-2,7-17 verify this. Those who always seek to please God, like the man after God's heart, David, identify with Ps 139. Surely, we cannot fail to see how consistent this is with what has already been said and with what follows.

Those who identify with OT and NT saints experience these words and know them to be true, for these words express like-minded biblical identifications shared by all the saints. None of us can run away from God nor from His Way and suppose we'll be safe. If we choose to reject His Way He will reject us. That's our perverse choice should we make it. In His omniscience God knows how, when, where and why each of us will turn to or away from Him. There is no contradiction between Divine foreknowledge and human freedom to choose. God knows how we shall use our free moral agency. God knows when and what will be the best circumstances to encourage us to accept His offer of salvation. But as with Cain, He also knows that no matter how favourable the environmental, cultural, social, and psychological circumstances, some will nevertheless reject His sovereignty over them, will refuse His complete Will over them, will not accept His Way as their way. Lucifer did this, as Is 14:13-14, Ezk 28:17-19 and Jn 8:44 show; Adam and Eve did this; Cain did this despite the appeals to him from the LORD (Gen 4:5-10; Jude 11); the Beast and False Prophet of the end-time will do this (see Dan 7:25; 11:36-39; Rev 13:1-18). And the two prophets of Rev 11, who will be God's witnesses to the whole world (v 4), will choose to endure successfully to the end.

A simple example and analogy of human foreknowledge is reflected in a parent's discerning of his child's behaviour. A parent may accurately or moderately accurately predict what the child will do and say in new foreseen and unforeseen situations. I have frequently predicted what my two daughters would do in all kinds of situations. God is perfectly omniscient and predicts everything each of us will do, say, think. God knows how we shall decide and what we shall do with the consequences of each decision, and when. The Eternal, in His omniscience, knows that in a future resurrection to human life those who are intractable and self-willed like Cain and Judas will still not repent despite a far more favourable environment for right decision-making. This merciful Almighty Father will raise those who have not had opportunity to hear the Gospel (Rev 20:5a)

The Christian experience of life, despite its trials and tribulations, is constantly filled with personal evidence that God is perfectly good and gracious. The merciful God exposes weaknesses, builds strengths, gives gifts and intervenes to protect us from the Evil One who hatefully sees the evidence of the saints' godly choices. David perceived that God's wisdom was infinite and he was over-awed by God's grace.

GOD'S FOREKNOWLEDGE OF OT SAINTS
Let's consider God's foreknowledge of OT saints whose understanding and experience were like David's.

Abraham, beginning in Gen 12, was given eternal promises that had a limited application to OT Israel, but the fullness of that Covenant continues to come through those whose names are in the Book of Life and who will be in the Holy City—Jews and Gentiles—peoples of all nations. The context tells us that Abraham was in Haran in northern Mesopotamia and that he had already left Ur, which at that time was a coastal city on the Persian Gulf.

Those who bless the children of Abraham are blessed. Those who curse those blessed by God are cursed by God (see Gen 27:29; Num 24:9; Mt 10:40-42; 18:5-6; Mk 9:41-42).

Gen 18:17-19 also records the words of the pre-incarnate Jesus Christ expressing the Father's words to the friend of God:

Gal 3:8-9,14,29, 5:16, 1Pet 2:9-10, Rev 7:1-8 and 14:1-5 show that the foreknown nation is the Israel of God, which is the assembly of the firstborn (Heb 12:22-23), and each has his/her name in the Book of Life. The nation is made up from those who are the spiritual descendants of Abraham. The NT makes it clear that the children (and household) of Abraham, as living stones of the spiritual temple, build and increase the House of God (1Pet 2:5,9-10; Eph 2:19-22).

The Messenger of God was sent to tell the barren wife of Manoah, the father-to-be of Samson, that she would become pregnant and give birth to a son.

Samson did deliver Israel from the debauched Philistines, but it was in many difficulties, with much complication, working through numerous errors, that he overcame (Heb 11:32-40).

Jeremiah was known to God before his birth. And although he went through many tribulations, even the desire to die prematurely, which he despairingly expressed in powerful poetry in 20:14-18, Jeremiah chose good rather than evil. He overcame because he struggled to always accept the grace and will of God.

And if we are called, chosen, and faithful, then each of us will be delivered to the end of our lives of overcoming, until we have finished the race we must run and have won the crown of glory promised to all the saints throughout history. There is no greater calling, no greater goal and purpose to be offered and to strive for. God knows if we will believe when offered the Faith, if we truly believe now, if we will not give up on believing Him! We can know if our belief is genuine and enduring—for God knows!

There are other OT examples similar to Abraham, Samson, David, Jeremiah. That being true, we should not be surprised that God gives a specific number of firstfruits in the first resurrection (see Rev 14). Though the number may be symbolic, 144,000, it is nevertheless specific; i.e., it seems that there will be a specific number of firstfruits.

John the Baptist was foreknown before his birth. Luke 1 speaks of Elizabeth being barren and the archangel Gabriel visiting her husband, Zechariah.

Each of us is called to give honour and glory to the Name of God, to give excellent answer to our calling, to shut the mouths of the ignorant, to reveal to ourselves and others that God is working His purposes in our lives, in the lives of other scattered saints, in man's history.

The apostle Paul speaks of his calling. Yes, his calling was exceptional, unusual, and powerful, as was John the Baptist's, but aren't we also called and given gifts and responsibilities (see 1Cor 12:4-11)?

Each of us has an individual and special calling which no other person can take from us—unless we let them bring our godliness to ruin. Each of us is our brother's keeper and must also show respect to what God is doing in all of the elect, wherever they might be. I listen to what any person says to me by inspiration of the Holy Spirit (Prov 1:20-27; 8:1-5). The Spirit is the Spirit of truth and inspires alertness, receptivity, and the spiritual means to hear the revelation of the Good Shepherd, Jesus Christ. The sheep know His Voice and the sheep recognize the real Shepherd even if they are temporarily lost (Jn 10:4-18). That voice could be through a mere babe in Christ or a non-Christian, as is illustrated in Josiah not heeding Pharaoh Necho (2Chr 35:20-23). Do we have ears that hear (Ps 8:2; Mt 11:25-29; 13:9; 21:15-16; Lk 10:21; Rev 3:22)?

There is plenty of biblical evidence that God calls people in various ways to serve His purposes other than calling them to the Gospel of Salvation during their own historical time. Cyrus, king of Medo-Persia, named about 150 years before he was born, is an amazing example whose life is given more detail in Herodotus' The Histories. Isaiah 45:1-4 speaks of this Gentile king called to serve God in a grand way in history, as was Nebuchadnezzar (Dan 2:37-45), and as would apply to many men and women who have shaped world history. Judas is another example who shaped history as will be the men—two prophets of God and two vile antagonists of God—described in Rev 11 and 13. All of them are specifically foreknown.

As I've said many times, if what we perceive of some Scripture is correct, that perception and understanding will remain coherent, consistent, and will increase as we search further. Our understanding becomes greater if we understand correctly. There is enough for a large book, if not books, on Divine foreknowledge. All I can do is attempt to offer a taste of the subject.

PREDESTINATION OF CHRISTIANS
The apostle Peter speaks about God's foreknowledge of those called as elect to sanctified life and who live by the power of God.

Eklektos is the Greek for elect, or elect one. It is related to lego, to speak; logos, word; eklegomai, to make a choice; ekloge, chosen (TDNT, IV, pp 69-192).

Foreknowledge, knowing in advance, is from the Greek, prognosis. Gnosis means knowledge and know is derived from gnosis. The verb is proginosko. The prefix pro means before. A skilled doctor's prognosis is his assessment of what will happen to the patient's future health on the basis of accurate discernment of what the doctor presently sees in his diagnosis. God's prognosis of our spiritual health is on the diagnosis of our entire spiritual health which He foresees before we are born.

The NKJ has foreordained for proginosko, i.e., foreknown, in 1Pet 1:20

Two of Paul's epistles have profound sections about predestination. Rom 8:28-30 speaks about it in the context of baptism (in Rom 6), the struggle against sin (in Rom 7), and then the works of God by the power of God, the Holy Spirit, in each of the saints. We're told that those who are led by the Spirit of God are His children (Rom 8:14,16). Those who do not have the Spirit of God are not His (v 9). The epistle to the church in Ephesus speaks similarly. Just as Christ was appointed and chosen to be the Lamb of God before the creation, so likewise those who will be Christ's and His Father's are appointed and chosen before the creation—before the universe came into existence, which was and is a manifestation of the omniscient power of God, which is His Spirit working. Dispensation, a common translation, is from oikonomia, which is derived from oikos, family, house, and nomos, which means, law. Oikonomia means management and administration of the House of God by God Almighty through Jesus Christ throughout history (see TDNT, V, pp 119-59). We could interpret verse 10 as: In the time process of the management of the House of God in the Law of God and in God's appointed time-scale, all things in heaven and earth, the whole creation, will come together (see Rom 8:19-22). CONCLUSION
Scripture reveals that the Almighty Father of us all defines predestination as a product of His foreknowledge. GOD in His omniscience has foreseen how all individuals will respond to His gracious and perfectly-timed offer of the Gospel. He has appointed to Eternal Life all those whom He has foreseen responding in pure faith and wholehearted obedience to His Son and to all His Word and Will. With that knowledge we are further assured that He will finish His work (Jn 4:34; 6:29; Rom 9:28-29).

How wonderful it is to realize we are not alone. We have many beloved brothers and sisters in the past, in the present, and more in the future. May God hasten the gathering of all His family—all the elect—all the saints foreknown as His faithful children (Rev 17:14). And may the Almighty, through the Good Shepherd of His Flock, give more grace, peace, strength and help draw us ever closer to the Father of us all—all who choose to love the Truth with all their heart, with all their strength, with all their being (Rev 22:21).

Go back to our Home Page