ECCLESIASTES
WHAT'S WORTH WORKING FOR?
© Paul Brydson  
The Church of God in Williamstown
WEB SITE: http://www.alphalink.com.au/~sanhub/index_.htm

WHAT'S WORTH DOING?
From its very beginning, the Book of Ecclesiastes confronts and shocks us perhaps more than any other book in the Bible.

What do you think of the person who wrote Ecclesiastes? The world's most famous pessimist? Few would call him an optimist. Perhaps you consider him a realist. In my study into this book, I have found its message surprisingly comforting, and a powerful weapon against the anxieties of life. Solomon wanted to know, "What is worth working for? What is worth doing?" Let's notice how this thought runs through his message: Why did Solomon ask such questions? I think because he saw so many examples—and had experiences himself—of wasted lives, misused lives, frustrated and disappointed lives. Here was a man who had a love of life and who earnestly desired to know how it could be best lived. Ecclesiastes isn't a book written by a cynical spectator of life. Only a man who was wrestling with the dilemma of life under the sun could write such an essay as we read in Ecclesiastes. Solomon is striving to answer some of the core questions of life: man works, he expends effort, but what is he working for?

To start with, let's note that Solomon is exploring in detail a theme expressed elsewhere in Scripture, namely, the nature of a world cursed to toil and frustration by God.

Paul also describes in summary what Solomon considers in detail: Let's go back to Solomon's exploration.

HEBEL
If you were writing an essay on the experience of life and you had to summarise your conclusion in a short, succinct saying, what would it be? Solomon gives us the phrase "Vanity of vanities! All is vanity." But this is actually an interpretation of what Solomon was saying. More literally, he says:

"Breath of a breath! The slightest breath! All is a breath!"
And then he also parallels this with the phrase "a striving after wind".

The word vanity, or breath, is the Hebrew hebel. It is interesting that this is also the name of the first saint—Hebel—Abel (Ge 4:2). So Solomon speaks to us in this metaphor—"All is a breath". It is therefore helpful to let the metaphor speak to us so we can draw our own conclusions rather than accept someone else's. He is saying that all things done under the sun are like a breath, like feeding on or striving after the wind. The metaphor of labouring for "breath", "feeding on the wind" is a graphic metaphor of man's life—labouring for something that gives fleeting satisfaction, but which then has to be given up, which cannot be retained, like beauty (Pr 31:30). We keep labouring (just as we keep breathing) again and again, but in the end we seem to gain nothing from it. We can't keep it. Everything done under the sun is like this metaphor of a breath. Let's consider how he drives home this point.

Man, in his toil "under the sun", living in a world subjected to sin (Ro 8:20), cannot hold on to anything of lasting value. Our efforts are like breathing, striving after the wind. This is the message of the Gospel. Elsewhere the same Gospel message is preached, with a different metaphor: (Isa 40:6-8; Job 14:12; Ps 90:5-6; 102:11; 103:14-18; 1Pe 1:24-25).

CYCLES—THE WORLD WEARIED BY REPETITIVE LABOUR
Let's go back to Ecclesiastes to see how Solomon further describes the world in which we live.

And man likewise is engaged in ceaseless, repetitive activity. His eyes and ears are never satisfied. Men crave for something new (Acts 17:21). But man is cursed in this cycle of repetitive activity, just like the creation, and so Solomon can conclude: Nature reveals this repetition without any seeming progress, as does human history from which man seems unable to learn. So much for the idea of evolution! And Solomon sums all this up by giving us the metaphor of 'it is all a breath'. Nature, like man, is like a breath, ever working but never ultimately filled or satisfied. However, within this scheme of regularity, we have a sense of consistency and stability; within this stability the wicked scoff at the idea of God and His promises and the righteous await their sure realisation (Eccl 2:17; 3:14-15; Mt 24:38,48; 2Pe 3:3-7). And it cannot be altered: Solomon now inserts a proverb to render his conclusion about the tediousness of the repetition into which man and creation are locked. The vanity of everything done under the sun is a situation that cannot be changed. What is twisted cannot be straightened; what is lacking, what is empty, cannot be made complete. The carnal mind cannot be changed. Sin will always produce this. Only with God can a way be made straight, or can something truly new come forth.

ANXIETY
So what do we labour for? We can work hard to build something up, but so often we will leave it behind for another who may not value it.

Ecclesiastes makes the point that nothing profitable is gained by man's toil under the sun. Solomon asked "What profit has a man from all his labor?" So, according to the teacher of Ecclesiastes, what does man gain from his labours? Solomon is not the only one to have such a view of the fruits of man's labours. Paul tells us what the rewards of a man's work are in this world: Or put another way, toiling away for profit and gain produces death. People work their guts out for years, and the wage they earn for their labour is death! And so Solomon came to hate life: However, these are not his final conclusions, but rather some of the difficult ground he traverses so we can better appreciate the advice he has for us. Solomon does not say these things to drive us to despair, which is the state in which so many live as they try to escape the meaninglessness of their lives. In spite of our sin, God is working to liberate all of creation from its bondage to decay. Therefore, even the perplexity of life can work out for the good of those who love God and who are called according to His purpose (Ro 8:19-28). God wants us to give up stupid illusions and embrace the true gift of life as He gives it, not as we labour for it. Solomon tells us we should work to remove such things from our hearts: LOOK
We have considered the word hebel, which is one of the major themes of Ecclesiastes. Another word also used often in Ecclesiastes (about 47 times), is the word ra'a. It means to see, to look, to centre one's interest and attention on, experience, consider. To illustrate the breadth of its meaning, here are a number of verses from Ecclesiastes that use this word ra'a. So where have we come to? Solomon has shown us that the whole of creation is stuck in this rut. All of man's efforts under the sun are like grasping (or gasping!) for wind. Labouring for knowledge and wisdom brings grief. Having fun is also shallow and temporary, as are personal achievements. Having come to these conclusions, what advice does Solomon therefore offer?

EAT, DRINK, ENJOY YOUR LABOUR

The word "enjoy" used in this verse is the word ra'a which, as we have seen, means much more than just physical enjoyment. Therefore Solomon is saying that we should enjoy, see, understand, consider the good in all our labours. The ability to enjoy what we have been given is better than striving for things we don't have. This is a gift of God. This gift is given to those who please God, while others are given the unsatisfying task of gathering what will be given to others. So it is more than just a matter of enjoyment. Part of the Gospel is learning to see clearly. Solomon tells us there is nothing better for us to do than to see what is before us, and to put our whole being into doing what is good, worthwhile and meaningful with it. Can we do this, or are our minds distracted by other worries, cares and desires? Solomon positively encourages this action: The apostle Paul draws the same conclusions as Solomon: In spite of the curse on man's work, God gives this to him as a gift that can be enjoyed (Eccl 3:13). Rather than anxiously striving for things that I cannot keep, and causing myself greater stress (Eccl 2:23), I need to learn to find enjoyment and good in what I have been given. This is the admonition of the Jesus Christ and the apostles: rejoice! The real lesson of life is learning to live by faith, to be content with what we have. There is something to be gained and to be grateful for in everything we experience.

Go back to our Home Page